Commanded + Domo to validate type/format of Commands and Events

It was an elegant “Eventsourcing and CQRS in Elixir” talk given by @vasspilka at ElixirConf EU 2021. It shows how to use the Commanded library by @slashdotdash to model a Bank domain with the Domain-Driven Design approach and make an event-driven system out of it.

Having the well-defined model with Command and Event structs, it still can be an issue to validate data coming from the User Interface and validate the consistency of casting commands and events in each other.

For example, the value of the bank account identifier should be both of binary type and have a specific format. That is different from other kinds of binary identifiers across the system.

One of the possible ways to solve the validation problems defined above is by using Domo library in Command and Event structs like that:

# defining the format precondition for value's type 
defmodule Bank do
  import Domo

  @type account_number() :: binary()
  precond account_number: &validate_account_number/1

  def validate_account_number(string) do
    if string =~ ~r/^[[:digit:]]{3}-[[:digit:]]{3}$/, do: :ok, else: {:error, "Account number should be of xxx-xxx, x = 0..9 format."}

# using Domo in the event struct
defmodule Bank.Core.Commands.DepositMoney do
  use Domo, ensure_struct_defaults: true
  # automatically adds new_ok/1 and new!/1 constructors

# using constructor in the Accounts context
defmodule Bank.Core.Accounts do
  def deposit_money(acc_id, amount) do
    [account_id: acc_id, amount: amount]
    |> DepositMoney.new_ok()
    |> maybe_dispatch(returning: :execution_result)

  defp maybe_dispatch({:ok, command}, opts), do: Bank.Core.Application.dispatch(command, opts)
  defp maybe_dispatch({:error, _message} = error, _opts), do: error

Then the following errors can be handled automatically:

iex(1)> Accounts.deposit_money(nil, 10)        
   account_id: "Invalid value nil for field :account_id of %Bank.Core.Commands.DepositMoney{}. Expected the value matching the <<_::_*8>> type."

iex(2)> Accounts.deposit_money("100102", 500)        
    account_id: "Account number should be of xxx-xxx, x = 0..9 format."

iex(3)> Accounts.deposit_money("100-102", -12)
   amount: "Invalid value -12 for field :amount of %Bank.Core.Commands.DepositMoney{}. Expected the value matching the non_neg_integer() type."

iex(4)> Accounts.deposit_money("100-102", 120)
{:ok, %Commanded.Commands.ExecutionResult{}} 

Domo makes it possible to associate a precondition (format validation) function with the given @type definition and adds new_ok/1 validating constructor and several others to a struct.

The consistency of commands and events is ensured with the call to the validating constructor.

See the complete Bank example from the @vasspilka’s talk seasoned with Domo on GitHub - IvanRublev/bank-commanded-domo.

More details about Domo Domo v1.3.2 — Documentation


Thank you so much!! I feel like I could have done a better job at presenting, hopefully I’ll improve my speaking next for next time :wink:

Domo looks awesome, I was actually looking for something like it for a while, I wonder how well it can work with typed_struct I use it a lot in micro_words.

Thank’s again for the kind words, I’ll play around and explore Domo in the weekend and give you some feedback. Cheers :slight_smile:

Hey @vasspilka,

Thank you.

I like to use typed_struct too. The library is fully compatible :smile:
Goes down to throwing use Domo into the module and using new!/1 constructor then.

It’d be nice to get to know how Domo works in your project.

Where can I see the talk?

Thanks to Barbara Trojecka for the link to the video:

1 Like