erlang_python embeds Python with true parallelism via sub-interpreters (each with its own GIL) or free-threading (no GIL). You get bidirectional communication: channels, async/await, and Python calling back into Erlang. Pythonx is designed for Livebook/Elixir with a single Python interpreter and shared GIL, which is enough for notebooks but limited for concurrent production workloads.
Afaik erlang_python is built to run Python applications inside the Erlang VM and inherit its efficiency.
I tried to read the code, but the project is huge and NIF part is around 15k lines of C code (thats around 5% of whole OTP C code size).
I think that it was generated, given that project is +90k lines in a month from you. Given that, it is strange to see that it is 2.1.0 version already. For me it feels more like its pre 1.0.0 version, given that it was rapidly developed and I assume was not used by anybody except you yet
Do you have any benchmarks? I am curious about how it compares to Snex, which uses erlang ports to spawn multiple interpreters and has very very tiny NIF surface. I think that erlang-python should be faster
Do you use it in production? What’s your use-case?
It’s used in a coming product and you can find it used in barrel_embed and some other products like hornbeam. recently I only merged and fixed . I’m pushing version when i introduce breaking change, also. The moment I start to use it for supported products it becomes 1.0.
Oh, so it takes around 5ms to do py:call(math, sqrt, [2.0])! Thats very impressive. By the way, https://hornbeam.dev/ looks very cool and promising too!
I will try to play with it locally on my machine some time soon
Then put together a sample project to test whether pooling Python workers from the BEAM side buys anything over straight Python. Turns out non-GIL Python is pretty capable on its own: https://github.com/nshkrdotcom/slither
That said, the whole stack is still a prototype — glued together with gRPC and architecturally rough. Feel free to steal anything useful. Really glad to see your project.