FizzBuzz in recursion?

taro

I’m overthinking FizzBuzz in Elixir, refactoring everything possible Elixir way.

Now I’m trying to find a recursive way to put an IO list together so it will result in ["Fizz", ["Buzz"]]. But I’m quite stuck, recursion is difficult to grasp. So I’ve decided to ask smarter people.

defmodule FizzBuzz do
  ...

  def change(num) do
    # Recurse in with an integer in closure
    # Recurse out leaving string each step
  end

  defp name_multiple(num) when rem(num, 3) == 0, do: "Fizz"
  defp name_multiple(num) when rem(num, 5) == 0, do: "Buzz"
  defp name_multiple(_), do: ""
end

I’m not asking for the simpler solutions of FizzBuzz. I want to join FizzBuzz instead of returning them separately, so it’s more extensible. I also tried to use multi-clause functions and guards as much as I can.

My previous solution is

defmodule FizzBuzz do
  @moduledoc """
  Name multiples. 

    * Multiples of 3 => "Fizz"
    * Multiples of 5 => "Buzz"

  Concatenates when many are applicable.

    * Multiples of 3 and 5 => "FizzBuzz"

  Unapplicable numbers remain intact.
  """

  @spec list(integer) :: list
  def list(max) when is_integer(max), do: list(1..max)

  @spec list(Enumerable.t()) :: list
  def list(enum), do: Enum.map(enum, &change/1)

  @spec change(integer) :: integer | String.t()
  def change(num) do
    num
    |> prefer(fizz(num))
    |> prefer(buzz(num))
  end

  defp prefer(old, new) when not new, do: old
  defp prefer(old, new) when not is_binary(old), do: new
  defp prefer(old, new), do: old <> new

  defp fizz(num) when rem(num, 3) == 0, do: "Fizz"
  defp fizz(_), do: false

  defp buzz(num) when rem(num, 5) == 0, do: "Buzz"
  defp buzz(_), do: false
end

2 comments

#algorithm #quiz

0 803 2

2023-02-15 18:53:36 UTC

Showing Posts 1 to 2

Show Best Posts
Show All (oldest first)
Show All (newest first)

Adzz

So the thing with recursion is you first want to ensure you know the conditions under which you want to stop recuring.

In this case that’s not clear, but I assume you want to halt once you have reached some maximum number of iterations. So let’s first call a recursive function, but implement the break condition:

defmodule FizBuzz do
  def change(max) do
     change(max, [], max - 1)
  end

  def change(_number, result, iterations) when iterations == 0 do
    result
  end 
end

If we call it like this FizzBuzz.change(0) we will be returned [].

Now we can add the other conditions

defmodule FizBuzz do
  def change(max) do
     change(max, [], max)
  end

  def change(number, result, iterations) when iterations <= 0 do
    result
  end

  def change(number, result, iterations) when rem(number, 15) == 0 do 
    change(number - 1, ["FizzBuzz" | result], iterations - 1)
  end

  def change(number, result, iterations) when rem(number, 5) == 0 do
    change(number - 1, ["Buzz" | result], iterations - 1)
  end

  def change(number, result, iterations) when rem(number, 3) == 0 do
    change(number - 1, ["Fizz" | result], iterations - 1)
  end

  def change(number, result, iterations) do
    change(number - 1, [number | result], iterations - 1)
  end
end

Post #1

100phlecs

I want to join FizzBuzz instead of returning them separately, so it’s more extensible

Here’s what I came up with.

defmodule FizzBuzz do
  def convert(num, lst \\ [])
  def convert(num, lst) when rem(num, 5) == 0, do: num |> extract(5) |> convert(["Buzz" | lst])
  def convert(num, lst) when rem(num, 3) == 0, do: num |> extract(3) |> convert(["Fizz" | lst])
  def convert(_num, lst) when length(lst) > 0, do: lst
  def convert(num, _lst), do: num

  defp extract(num, factor) when rem(num, factor) == 0, do: num |> div(factor) |> extract(factor)
  defp extract(num, _factor), do: num
end

maybe_join = fn
  elem when is_list(elem) -> Enum.join(elem)
  num when is_integer(num) -> num
end

1..100
|> Enum.map(&FizzBuzz.convert/1)
|> Enum.map(maybe_join)

Post #2

— All posts loaded —