How to test and assert order of elements in LiveView?

Have you considered using Floki to parse your HTML output? I’m sure you’ll find your way with it.

In LiveViewTest helper is a function element/3 that you use to retrieve html elements from your view and then validate the elements. The documentation has some nice examples:

I would also recommend to keep the tests of views simple and check only that the important stuff is there.

Move the ordering of your students to a public function and test that function. This will make testing so much easier.

I’m working through this same issue right now; testing an ordering function in LiveView where users can drag divs to re-order them.

To the best of my knowledge element/3 will throw if more than one item matches. It seems like there is no way to do this except for using something like Floki? If anyone has any other ides or suggestions I’d love to hear them.

I just take the simple boneheaded approach:

insert(
  :list,
  items: [
    build(:item, name: "One"),
    build(:item, name: "Two"),
    build(:item, name: "Three")
  ]
)

assert lv
       |> element(".list-container")
       |> render() =~ ~r/One.*Two.*Three/s

The s regex modifier allows matching over line breaks.

Oh snap yeah that’s a much simpler idea. Thanks.

I had started a PR for GitHub - mohamed-tallarium/Mononcle · GitHub (which uses Floki to represent some higher-level assertions) that would take a tab-separated string to represent an expected table and compare it against the table in the DOM.

(Certainly I’ve used that technique in other environments to make the expected table state as clear as possible)

HtmlQuery has a table function: HtmlQuery — HtmlQuery v4.4.0

iex> html = "<table> <tr><th>A</th><th>B</th><th>C</th></tr> <tr><td>1</td><td>2</td><td>3</td></tr> </table>"

iex> HtmlQuery.table(html)

[
  ["A", "B", "C"],
  ["1", "2", "3"]
]

It also has a bunch of other useful functions for parsing HTML. It pairs nicely with Pages, a library that implements the page pattern for UI testing and works with controllers and LiveViews without the involvement of a web browser.

So I don’t know why I never thought of this before but out of the box you can use CSS selectors along with has_element?/3 for much more fine-grained and reliable results than my current regex solution:

assert has_element?(lv, ".my-list li:nth-child(1)", "One")
assert has_element?(lv, ".my-list li:nth-child(2)", "Two")
assert has_element?(lv, ".my-list li:nth-child(3)", "Three")

cc: @travisf

PhoenixTest now has a very clean way to do this:

visit(conn, "/")
|> assert_has(".my-list li", "One", at: 1)
|> assert_has(".my-list li", "Two", at: 2)
|> assert_has(".my-list li", "Three", at: 3)

I think the assert_has/4 function has been removed.

The current code for this would now look like that:

visit(conn, "/")
|> assert_has(".my-list li", text: "One", at: 1)
|> assert_has(".my-list li", text: "Two", at: 2)
|> assert_has(".my-list li", text: "Three", at: 3)