jan-swiatek
MVC vs LiveView
Hi,
I’m learning Phoenix for a while and I don’t get the differences between MVC and LiveView. When should I use which, or how to mix them properly? Can you give me some examples as well?
Most Liked
derek-zhou
My only advice is don’t blend static view and LiveView until you are very comfortable with both of them. Limit your choice first; if the problem space is too vast you can easily get lost exploring.
tfwright
This seems like a strange question, assuming you mean Model/View/Controller, since the latter is a general pattern for building software and LiveView is a very specific framework for rendering HTML server-side. The default Phoenix code structure already encourages a sort of MVC structure by encouraging you to keep business logic (Model) in contexts, and providing a template system so you can keep your mark up (View) separate from your event handlers (Controller). So really it’s only left to us as Phoenix LiveView users to try and respect the boundaries the framework has already put in place, and not put functions that generate HTML in contexts, or general business logic in specific live views, etc…
If you provide some more specific examples of things you’re confused about, maybe we can give you more specific pointers.
travisf
Based on the original question, with Phoenix, if you are following their patterns, you are already building with models and views. As @cmo mentioned, the C part of MVC is controllers, if you are using LiveViews you will have a live folder rather than a controllers folder. I’m not sure it’s harmful to think of them as being drastically different, the live folder will act as a sort of controller for data from the model and pass it to the view.
This is of course an over simplification but I think in theory it’s a good way to think of things.
As @cmo mentioned using controllers vs LiveView absolutely depends but you are not wedded to either one, you can create a controller for some pages that will have traditional HTTP request-responses and frontend JavaScript and LiveView for dynamic pages where you want to push data to and from the client without a page refresh. Personally, I find working with traditional HTTP request-responses tends to get pretty limited if I’m trying to build an interactive user experience so I tend to stick with LiveView as a default but it’s conditional on what the page is.







