Review my code - duration measurement & convert to a human easy readable scientific format

Hi all, as I’m always trying to improve my code.
Is anyone of you Elixir Pros interested into review my following code?

This module will convert duration measurements into a human easy readable scientific format.
What I mean by this.
I always hated if an uptime / or downtime measurement told me e.g. up since 1 y 21 d 5 h 5 min 5 s.
In this case 1 y 21 d would be totally enough for myself.

So the conversion scheme I’m using here is very opinionated.
In case of any unit value below 10, I will additionally add the value of the next unit. Above I don’t.
e.g.

- `1 s _ ms` - `9 s _ ms`
- `10 s ` - `59 s`

I would be very thankful if anybody would give me his opinion to my code below.
If you would do something in Elixir best practice completely different for this use case …

defmodule Tool.Timer do
  @moduledoc """
  Time measurement tool for performance & uptime testing.
  Can convert a duration to a human easy understandable scientific format.
  """

  @base_unit :nanosecond
  @unit_shift_factor 10

  @second 1
  @minute @second * 60
  @hour @minute * 60
  @day @hour * 24
  @year @day * 365

  @doc """
  Returns monotonic system time in @base_unit
  """
  @spec now() :: integer()
  def now, do: System.monotonic_time(@base_unit)

  @doc """
  Calculate time difference to a given start time (e.g. from `now/0`).
  Return duration in @base_unit.
  """
  @spec diff(integer(), integer()) :: integer()
  def diff(start_time, end_time \\ now()) do
    end_time - start_time
  end

  @doc """
  Calculate time difference to a given start time (e.g. from `now/0`).
  Return duration in a human easy understandable scientific format.
  In: `-576460349095935368`
  Out:
  - `1 ns` - `999 ns`
  - `1 μs _ ns` - `9 μs _ ns`
  - `10 μs` - `999 μs`
  - `1 ms _ μs` - `9 ms _ μs`
  - `10 ms ` - `999 ms`
  - `1 s _ ms` - `9 s _ ms`
  - `10 s ` - `59 s`
  - `1 min _ s` - `59 min _ s`
  - `1 h _ min` - `23 h _ min`
  - `1 d _ h` - `364 d _ h`
  - `1 y _ d` - `_ y _ d`
  """
  @spec diff_human(integer(), integer(), System.time_unit()) :: binary()
  def diff_human(start_time, end_time \\ now(), base_unit \\ @base_unit) do
    diff_base = diff(start_time, end_time)
    diff_nano = System.convert_time_unit(diff_base, base_unit, :nanosecond)
    time_conversion(diff_nano)
  end

  # everything below system precision
  defp time_conversion(time) when time === 0,
    do: "< #{system_precision()}"

  # nanoseconds (ns) only
  defp time_conversion(time) when time < 1_000,
    do: unit_fraction_string(time, :nanosecond)

  # microseconds (μs) + nanoseconds (ns)
  defp time_conversion(time) when time < 1_000 * @unit_shift_factor do
    list_to_string([
      unit_fraction_string(time, :microsecond),
      unit_fraction_string(time, :nanosecond)
    ])
  end

  # microseconds (μs) only
  defp time_conversion(time) when time < 1_000_000,
    do: unit_fraction_string(time, :microsecond)

  # milliseconds (ms) + microseconds (μs)
  defp time_conversion(time) when time < 1_000_000 * @unit_shift_factor do
    list_to_string([
      unit_fraction_string(time, :millisecond),
      unit_fraction_string(time, :microsecond)
    ])
  end

  # milliseconds (ms) only
  defp time_conversion(time) when time < 1_000_000_000,
    do: unit_fraction_string(time, :millisecond)

  # seconds (s) + milliseconds (ms)
  defp time_conversion(time) when time < 1_000_000_000 * @unit_shift_factor do
    list_to_string([
      unit_fraction_string(time, :second),
      unit_fraction_string(time, :millisecond)
    ])
  end

  # seconds (s) only
  defp time_conversion(time) when time < @minute * 1_000_000_000,
    do: unit_fraction_string(time, :second)

  # minutes (min) + seconds (s)
  defp time_conversion(time) when time < @hour * 1_000_000_000 do
    list_to_string([
      unit_subset_fraction_string(time, :minute, @minute, 60),
      unit_subset_fraction_string(time, :second, @second, 60)
    ])
  end

  # hours (h) + minutes (min)
  defp time_conversion(time) when time < @day * 1_000_000_000 do
    list_to_string([
      unit_subset_fraction_string(time, :hour, @hour, 60),
      unit_subset_fraction_string(time, :minute, @minute, 60)
    ])
  end

  # days (d) + hours (h)
  defp time_conversion(time) when time < @year * 1_000_000_000 do
    list_to_string([
      unit_subset_fraction_string(time, :day, @day, 365),
      unit_subset_fraction_string(time, :hour, @hour, 24)
    ])
  end

  # years (y) + days (d)
  @spec time_conversion(integer()) :: binary()
  defp time_conversion(time) do
    list_to_string([
      unit_subset_fraction_string(time, :year, @year, 365),
      unit_subset_fraction_string(time, :day, @day, 365)
    ])
  end

  # will return the human readable system precision
  @spec system_precision :: binary
  defp system_precision do
    parts_per_second = System.convert_time_unit(1, :second, :native)
    precision_nano = round(1 / parts_per_second * 1_000_000_000)

    # to avoid a infinite loop on value 0
    precision =
      case precision_nano do
        x when x > 0 -> x
        _ -> 1
      end

    time_conversion(precision)
  end

  # unit fraction for everything below seconds
  @spec unit_fraction_string(integer(), atom()) :: binary()
  defp unit_fraction_string(time, unit) do
    fraction =
      time
      |> System.convert_time_unit(:nanosecond, unit)
      |> Integer.mod(1_000)

    human_readable_unit(fraction, unit)
  end

  # unit fraction for everything above seconds
  @spec unit_subset_fraction_string(integer(), atom(), integer(), integer()) :: binary()
  defp unit_subset_fraction_string(time, unit, fraction_divisor, subset_divisor) do
    fraction =
      time
      |> System.convert_time_unit(:nanosecond, :second)
      |> Integer.floor_div(fraction_divisor)
      |> Integer.mod(subset_divisor)

    human_readable_unit(fraction, unit)
  end

  # join value with unit
  @spec human_readable_unit(integer(), atom()) :: binary()
  defp human_readable_unit(fraction, unit) do
    cond do
      fraction > 0 -> Integer.to_string(fraction) <> " " <> unit_abbreviation(unit)
      true -> nil
    end
  end

  # unit abbreviations
  @spec unit_abbreviation(atom()) :: binary()
  defp unit_abbreviation(:nanosecond), do: "ns"
  defp unit_abbreviation(:microsecond), do: "μs"
  defp unit_abbreviation(:millisecond), do: "ms"
  defp unit_abbreviation(:second), do: "s"
  defp unit_abbreviation(:minute), do: "min"
  defp unit_abbreviation(:hour), do: "h"
  defp unit_abbreviation(:day), do: "d"
  defp unit_abbreviation(:year), do: "y"

  # join list to string
  @spec list_to_string(list()) :: binary()
  defp list_to_string(list) do
    list
    # remove nil values from list
    |> Enum.filter(& &1)
    |> Enum.join(" ")
  end
end

Edit:

  • Updated with the already mentioned changes from david_ex.

Here’s some low-hanging fruit:

Instead of

Integer.mod(
        Integer.floor_div(System.convert_time_unit(time, :nanosecond, :second), fraction_divisor),
        subset_divisor
      )

you can pipe:

time
|> System.convert_time_unit(:nanosecond, :second)
|> Integer.floor_div(fraction_divisor),
|> Integer.mod(subset_divisor)

Instead of

defp unit_abbreviation(unit) when unit === :nanosecond, do: "ns"

simply use

defp unit_abbreviation(:nanosecond), do: "ns"

Instead of

Enum.join([Integer.to_string(fraction), unit_abbreviation(unit)], " ")

use

Integer.to_string(fraction) <> " " <> unit_abbreviation(unit)

or

"#{Integer.to_string(fraction)} #{unit_abbreviation(unit)}"

(although using Enum.join is useful when you have many inputs to join).

2 Likes

Wow. Thanks a lot - I like the suggested changes.

You might want to look into using the Timex library that supports a duration structure.

I know Timex - and there are some similarities to my implementation.
But for the fun of programming and learning Elixir,
and always trying to avoid any dependencies up first,
I decided to try to find my own solution.

1 Like

Here’s another approach using some of my CLDR libs:

defmodule Elapsed do
  @to ~U[2019-10-01 11:00:00.0000Z]
  @from ~U[2019-01-01 09:35:00.000450Z]
  
  def time_in_words(options \\ []) do
    precision = Keyword.get(options, :precision, 3)
    @to
    |> DateTime.diff(@from, :microsecond)
    |> Cldr.Unit.new(:microsecond)
    |> Cldr.Unit.decompose([:year, :month, :day, :hour, :minute])
    |> Enum.take(precision)
    |> Cldr.Unit.to_string(options)
  end
end

Examples:

iex> Elapsed.time_in_words                           
"8 months, 29 days, and 17 hours"
iex> Elapsed.time_in_words locale: "fr"
"8 mois, 29 jours et 17 heures"
iex> Elapsed.time_in_words precision: 2              
"8 months and 29 days"
iex> Elapsed.time_in_words precision: 2, locale: "fr"
"8 mois et 29 jours"
iex> Elapsed.time_in_words precision: 2, list_options: [format: :unit_short]              
"8 months, 29 days"
iex> Elapsed.time_in_words style: :narrow
"8m, 29d, and 17h"
iex> Elapsed.time_in_words style: :narrow, precision: 2
"8m and 29d"
iex> Elapsed.time_in_words style: :narrow, precision: 2, list_options: [format: :unit_narrow]
"8m 29d"
4 Likes

Good to know - your CLDR units lib is quite impressive!

By the way. I like the way to use DateTime to calculate the diff.
In case a diff must be calculated with persistent saved DateTime beyond an Erlang system restart.
As I’m not sure how System.monotonic_time will behave then.

But I would have to forgo on the precision of nanoseconds.