Hello friends!
So I’ve been ticking away at a project to showcase the possible use case for using Ash and Phoenix at my place of work.
I feel like I’m missing a few things about Ash (or maybe it’s just Elixir) to fully flesh out this example project.
For starters, here’s a more “”“real world”“” example of an Ash Resource that outlines what I’m trying to do:
defmodule MyProject.Entities.State do
@moduledoc """
"""
use Ash.Resource,
data_layer: AshPostgres.DataLayer,
extensions: AshJsonApi.Resource
attributes do
uuid_primary_key :id
attribute :name, :string do
allow_nil? false
end
attribute :opt_out, :boolean do
allow_nil? false
default false
end
end
actions do
# Exposes default built in actions to manage the resource
defaults [:create, :read, :update, :destroy]
# Defines custom read action which fetches post by id.
read :by_id do
# This action has one argument :id of type :uuid
argument :id, :uuid, allow_nil?: false
# Tells us we expect this action to return a single result
get? true
filter expr(id == ^arg(:id))
end
end
code_interface do
define_for MyProject.Entities
define :create, action: :create
define :read_all, action: :read
define :update, action: :update
define :destroy, action: :destroy
define :get_by_id, args: [:id], action: :by_id
end
relationships do
belongs_to :country, MyProject.Entities.Country
has_many :counties, MyProject.Entities.County
has_many :cities, MyProject.Entities.City
end
aggregates do
count :number_of_counties, :counties do
description "Nubmer of counties in a state."
filter expr(opt_out == false)
end
list :counties_in_state, :counties, :id do
description "List of counties in the given state."
filter expr(opt_out == false)
end
count :number_of_cities, :cities do
description "Number of cities in a state"
filter expr(opt_out == false)
end
list :cities_in_state, :cities, :id do
description "List of cities in the given state."
filter expr(opt_out == false)
end
end
postgres do
table "states"
repo MyProject.Repo
end
json_api do
type "states"
routes do
base "/states"
get :by_id, route: "/:id", action: :by_id
index :read, route: "/all"
post :create
end
end
end
So a couple of questions:
-
How do I call an aggregate or calculation in a read action?
list is very useful in a lot of situations that I’d be facing.
-
Is it possible or even recommended to cache the results of read actions via Cachex?
They will be used in the json_api section and the result of the some read actions can be quite large, some results might even be from the list type of aggregate or even more advanced calculations. Of course abusing MATERIALIZED VIEW is an option, but is that always recommended first before any advanced caching mechanisms?
-
You can use load to load the aggregates/calculations. You can do it on a query: Ash.Query.load(query, [:cities_in_state]) or on records that you already have with Api.load(some_data, [:cities_in_state]).
-
You can cache Ash responses, but all of the normal caveats/issues arise from doing that kind of thing 
We actually do something similar for data that essentially never changes in ash_hq. https://github.com/ash-project/ash_hq/blob/main/lib/ash_hq/docs/resources/library/library.ex#L16
read :read do
primary? true
argument :check_cache, :boolean do
default true
end
prepare AshHq.Docs.Library.Preparations.CheckCache
end
defmodule AshHq.Docs.Library.Preparations.CheckCache do
@moduledoc """
Checks a simple agent cache for libraries
"""
use Ash.Resource.Preparation
def prepare(query, _, _) when query.arguments.check_cache == true do
Ash.Query.before_action(query, fn query ->
AshHq.Docs
|> Ash.Filter.Runtime.filter_matches(
AshHq.Docs.Library.Agent.get(),
query.filter
)
|> case do
{:ok, results} ->
results =
results
|> then(fn results ->
if query.offset do
Enum.drop(results, query.offset)
else
results
end
end)
|> then(fn results ->
if query.limit do
Enum.take(results, query.limit)
else
results
end
end)
|> Ash.Sort.runtime_sort(query.sort)
Ash.Query.set_result(query, {:ok, results})
{:error, _} ->
query
end
end)
end
def prepare(query, _, _) do
query
end
end
2 Likes
Okay. I think I’m getting the flow of things, but let me verify you. I think Java and Hibernate have just poisoned my brain so it’s definitely a lot of new things to try and grasp.
-
If getting an item/some items based on a single attribute of a defined resource, we can do
read :by_attr do
arguments :attr, :type, allow_nil?: false
get? true
filter expr(attr == ^arg(:attr))
end
-
If getting an item/some items involves something a bit more complex (i.e. checking API permissions before everything else) we can use prepare with a defined module that contains just a prepare function that can take up to 3 arguments.
-
prepare is used for, well, preparing the results of a read action.
-
If wanting to get or rather “load” an aggregate or calculated field, we can use Ash.Query.load.
Ash.Query.load(query, [:some_aggregate_field])
We can use this in another separately defined module and call it in the read action.
# Inside of the State Resource
code_interface do
define_for MyProject.Resoruces.State
define :cities_in_state, args: [:state_id]
end
read :cities_in_state do
argument :state_id, :uuid, allow_nil?: false
get? true
pagination offset?: true, default_limit: 50, countable: true
filter expr(id == ^arg(:id))
# I would assume a more generic
# MyProject.Utils.Resources.States.GetAggregate :aggregate_name
# might be considered "better" in some cases, but
# I don't recall how to pass in an argument in that context
prepare MyProject.Utils.Resources.States.GetListOfCities
end
# Inside MyProject.Utils.Resources.States.GetListOfCities
# Not entirely sure if doing a guard for permission checks
# here is "better" or idiomatic in Ash
def prepare(query, _, _) when check_if_some_permission_passes do
Ash.Query.load(query, [:cities_in_state])
|> case do
{:ok, results} ->
# probably would transform the resulting
# Resource in a way that doesn't include things like
# foreign keys that aren't necessary to see in a UI
Ash.Query.set_result(query, {:ok, results})
{:error, _} ->
# probably would actually give a helpful message in a real world situation
query
end
end
We can then use this in as MyProject.Resources.State.cities_in_state(:some_state_id), and I believe we use it in a Api.read or Api.get! but I’m still trying to get that all straight in my head by going through the docs.
-
In the json_api section, we can do the following:
# Inside of MyProject.Resources.State
json_api do
type "states"
routes do
base "/states"
get: :by_id, route: "/:id", action: :by_id
get: :cities_in_state, route: "/cities/:state_id", action: :cities_in_state
end
end
Hopefully I’m not too far gone and I’m mostly following the flow of using Ash.
Yep, this is all good with one exception of #4, only slight semantics.
# checking if some permission passes, I would suggest using the built in policy authorizer
# and field policies. Field policies, for instance, will prevent viewing specific fields based on specific criteria, allowing you to just load what you want and things they can't see will come back with the value `%Ash.ForbiddenField{}`
def prepare(query, _, _) when check_if_some_permission_passes do
# Ash.Query.load doesn't do it in line. It happens when the query is run
Ash.Query.load(query, [:cities_in_state])
|> case do
{:ok, results} ->
Ash.Query.set_result(query, {:ok, results})
{:error, _} ->
# probably would actually give a helpful message in a real world situation
query
end
If you want to some how transform the query results, it looks like this:
Ash.Query.after_action(query, fn query, results ->
{:ok, do_something_with(results)}
end)
end
You won’t typically need to use Ash.Query.set_result unless you’re writing something that “pre-empts” the action (like a cache check plus result setter). But keep in mind if you want to use set_result you typically will want to use it in a before_action hook:
Ash.Query.before_action(query, fn query ->
case check_cache(query) do
{:ok, cached_result} ->
Ash.Query.set_result(query, cached_result)
:error ->
...
end
end)
Oh okay, that actually makes it a lot clearer to understand.
I guess my only question left would be is if there’s a recommended way to organize multiple preparations for a single Ash Resource.
In the real world case at work, we’d probably be using a lot of Ash.Query.load and Ash.Query.after_action for getting the results of many different aggregates or calculations and changing the shape of the data in order to properly display it in places, so keeping all of those functions group in the same module would be useful.
Why would you need to use after_action to display loaded data? Loading it automatically puts it in the results. I’d suggest that, if you want to do lots of transformation of the results, your better bet would be to use generic actions and not after action hooks.
action :some_name, {:array, :map} do
constraints [fields: [....]]
run fn input, _ ->
data = run_a_read_action(...)
transform_the_data(data)
end
end
Why would you need to use after_action to display loaded data?
Sorry, I worded that wrong.
after_action wouldn’t be for displaying data, we would use it for a read action to transform the data. So for certain API endpoints we can just called Ash.Api.get! or whichever function to call the read action, and that way we can limit the logic in endpoints.
Like a service in Spring that specifically gets data an endpoint will send out contains most of the logic to transform the data, as opposed to doing it in the endpoint itself.
EDIT: But I do see your point on generic actions
