How do you approach exploratory programming in Elixir?

crispinb

The background to this is that I’ve (a) recently been doing some Clojure and am slightly addicted to the REPL-connected editor, and (b) I’m a total Elixir beginner (1 week in), so all my coding is at this stage “exploratory” (playing with examples from what I’m reading, trying out Kernel functions, etc).

Here’s what I’ve come up with so far:

iex: fine for one-liners, but a bit clumsy for anything more, and I’d much rather use an editor (and preferably the same editor I would use for real code)
iex -S mix, then calling on functions in files, reloading after edits: better, but still more friction than I’d like
via unit tests, writing small tests for the exploratory code & running mix test. A variation here is to use fswatch to run tests on every file save, but I haven’t got this working yet.
again via unit tests, but triggering tests from the editor (in my case using GitHub - adamzapasnik/vscode-elixir-test-explorer: VSCode Elixir test explorer · GitHub).

The final one above seems the most fluent approach so far, definitely workable, though ideally I’d like not to have to write tests for this kind of very transient exploratory code.

Any other ideas? I realise I’m not going to get a lisp-style repl experience (which is fine - Elixir has its own virtues), but something in that direction would be nice. A non-clojure example I quite like is Quokka for javascript/typescript.

9 comments

#tools #newbie

1 2895 9

2022-05-25 10:13:03 UTC

Showing Posts 1 to 9

Show Best Posts
Show All (oldest first)
Show All (newest first)

hauleth

Well, you can start the “REPL-like” server that will receive the code, and then will use Code.eval_string/3 to execute whatever you throw at it. It will provide similar experience to the SLIME.

About unit testing, what I am using is entr. So you need to list all files in your project (I am using rg -l -telixir '', but you can use git ls-files instead) and then make it to output name of the changed file entr echo /_ that will pass the changed files to mix test --listen-on-stdin --stale. So whole CLI will look like:

rg -l -telixir '' | entr echo /_ | mix test --listen-on-stdin --stale

Now it will changed tests on each save.

Post #1

Marcus

Maybe you will find exsync and mix-test.watch useful.

Post #2

crispinb

Thanks for the options, @hauleth & @Marcus. For now I think unit tests with a watch are going to be the best approach. I don’t want to spend much time on tooling for now - learning Elixir & Phoenix will be enough cognitive load

Would like to look into the option of sending selected code from the editor to be eval’d at a later stage though.

Post #3

dhruvp

I just finished going though a Common Lisp book (Gentle Introduction to Symbolic Programming) and really like the repl driven development. I also learned some Emacs along the way and that’s the editor I am using to learn Elixir. Currently going through the book Programming Elixir >= 1.6

Looking for a similar learning/development approach in elixir, where I code in the editor and verify the code is correct by evaluating the text in the editor, the text is evaluated against an elixir repl. This is very handy because there are times where I just want to check if the code is correct without leaving the editor.

Here are the tools/packages I am using:

Editor: Emacs
Emacs Packages for elixir:

inf-elixir: GitHub - J3RN/inf-elixir: An Emacs plugin for interacting with an Elixir REPL · GitHub
lsp-mode: Elixir - LSP Mode - LSP support for Emacs
elixir-mode: GitHub - elixir-editors/emacs-elixir: Emacs major mode for Elixir · GitHub

If you need a detailed setup, let me know, I can push it to a github repo.

Post #4

crispinb

Nice. Just what I would want if I used emacs. It’s one of the missing parts of the elixir ecosystem more widely.

Post #5

mindok

If I was starting out and wanting to play around with code, LiveBook (https://livebook.dev/) would probably be my #1 choice now. Instant feedback, nice formatting etc.

Post #6

crispinb

Agreed, it’s terrific. Not exactly the same as using your own REPL-linked editor (different keybindings etc), but with lots of other great possibilities.

Post #7

mattbaker

This might be what you meant by “reload” but just in case: if you haven’t found it r/1 In IEx will let you recompile a module on the fly, i.e. r(MyProject.MyModule). Beats terminating and restarting IEx!

At one point I had a hacked together VS Code extension that let you recompile the current file you were editing in an attached IEx session but I never followed through to ship it.

Post #8

crispinb

I do know about r/1 now but the question was a while back and I have no idea whether I did or not back then (or whether that was what I meant by ‘reload’). So thanks from my erstwhile self!

Ironically (or sadly from this perspective) I’m doing more with Rust right now than Elixir, so I’m even further distant from REPLy goodness.

Post #9

— All posts loaded —