Exploring Elixir E2: How fast is Elixir 1.5?

Elixir1.5.0-rc0 and OTP 20 are significant releases, full of features, bug fixes and optimizations. I was really curious as to how the optimizations listed in the release notes actually stacked up, so I bechmarked a few of them. This screencast shows the results of bechmarking pattern matching of maps, ets table creation, and ets insertion/lookup with Elixir 1.5 on OTP 20 vs Elixir 1.4 on OTP 18.

The results are extremely encouraging, and as a result of these measurements I can hardly wait to move all my projects to Elixir 1.5 / OTP 20.

All the usual caveats about benchmarks apply here, but as a comparison between the two versions I think it is a valid set of measuremnts as they were run on the same hardware and OS on an as-quiet-as-I-could-reasonably-make-my-laptop … not optimal conditions, but good enough to tease useful comparison numbers out of it.

For those curious, I benchmarked it on a i7-4500U laptop with 8GB RAM and a 256GB SSD drive. YMMV.

p.s. I had wanted to post the new episode on the weekend, but realized after making a first revision of the video that it was just simply too long and covered too much … as a result I ended up splitting the video into two parts, and there will be an “Extra” screencast coming in a bit that covers quite a few of the feature improvements in Elixir 1.5 w/OTP 20 … but that meant the upload was delayed until today … meh. Who needs schedules? :wink:

33 Likes

Yeah, responding to yourself is lame … but here I am anyways :wink:

Code repository that goes with this series can be found here: https://github.com/aseigo/exploring-elixir

Note that it is not a “coherent application” but rather all the snippets and bits I use in the episodes (including some that get left on the cutting room floor … ), but someone on reddit asked so there it is.

Also, the Extras episode noting a number of highlight features from Elixir 1.5 / OTP 20 is up as well:

13 Likes

Thanks for posting those videos and the interesting insights :slight_smile:

2 Likes

My pleasure; I’m just glad if someone else finds them interesting / useful as well! Cheers …

3 Likes

Thanks for your work! Rather useful. Still, i think, video format is not optimal for such payload, I’d prefer plain old article/blog post - way easier to navigate

3 Likes

Noooooooooo… screencasts are awesome @thousandsofthem :lol:

@aseigo and what he’s doing reminds me very much of Ryan Bates and Railscasts :003:

Best of both worlds would be to have show notes or asciicasts (like Railscasts did).

4 Likes

I actually agree that blog posts are better for archival and more “serious” reading. Thankfully there are a number of those for Elixir already … though perhaps I will also do one of those one day (I used to blog nearly daily for other projects I participated in) …

BUT … videos have a few benefits: they show visually what is happening and how it can come together in more or less real-time, something that is hard to replicate with a blog. Videos are also something to sit and consume almost casually, and as such they compliment and augment the written word with something a bit more like entertainment. There’s also something to be said about the “touch” of the human voice … for some people it’s more enjoyable …

So I think we need ALL of these forms of media to communicate the great things we love in Elixir and the BEAM ecosystem …

BTW … The next episode will be back to “live coding” again, which is also really hard to replicate in blog entry …

5 Likes

I’d prefer static/dynamic articles as well, video is not something I can watch until I get home, at which home life often blocks me from doing so. ^.^;

Video snippets on a page that have no audio are good though (I can ‘kind of’ watch videos at work, just no speakers thus no sound).

3 Likes

There’s one more optimisation that is missing from the videos - record pattern matching (or rather pattern matching on tuples where the first element is an atom) was also optimised. This also applies to ok and error tuples, so should be also visible in Elixir. I’m not sure how big of an improvement it is, though.

4 Likes

Ooooh, I missed that one entirely! Maybe I’ll sneak in a “one more thing …” in Episode 3 if it does turn out to be visible … neat.

Two other sets of improvements, Calendar enhancements and child_spec/1, will be subjects of future episodes on their own, so I skipped over them in these ones. …

4 Likes

Oh man, you guys are really making me seriously consider picking up the blogging again and doing a companion blog to the videos … well, we’ll seeeeee! :slight_smile:

3 Likes

Definitely higher visibility!   :smiley:

1 Like

Check the Railscasts link I posted - I reckon an accompanying asciicast would be enough :003:

http://railscasts.com/episodes/400-what-s-new-in-rails-4

Here’s the ASCIIcast: http://railscasts.com/episodes/400-what-s-new-in-rails-4?view=asciicast

There are loads of blogs out there, we defo need more quality screencasts imho.

2 Likes

I would really like to read about that performance comparison. When something is written I can skim it to see if it’s worthwhile my time. With videos… i don’t even bother. My experience with videos is that most of the time a 5 min content is dragged on for way to much time. And you neither can skim a video, nor get back easily to a particular moment that’s interesting. When it comes to programming, videos are good for… wait they’re not good for anything :frowning:

Update. I just read it again, and want to clarify one thing. It’s not that I am attacking you. Or that I cant appreciate someones work, just because it’s video, it’s not like that at all. It’s just that I’d much rather read a chunk of text, than watch a video (unless it’s a TV show or smth :wink: ). And I believe there are more people people like me and thats why I believe you would find at least few readers (if not many) for your blog if articles would be about interesting topics. :slight_smile:

Oh I always loved those ASCII casts :thumbsup: I really makes you think, that the creator value reader/watcher time, which is very rare.

5 Likes

So I’ve benchmarked this now; it’ll be in Episode 3 Extra … and I think you’ll be happily surprised about how big of an improvement it is …

2 Likes

Thanks for the update, I think it is good to keep these thing civil, esp for other people reading the threads … but just so you know -> I had already read it this way :slight_smile: I’m used to people having different senses of humor, etc. onilne by this point …

That said … I’ll address the issue of an “asciicast” in Episode 3 Extra (sorry, no asciicast this week, buuuut… )

2 Likes

Great :thumbsup:

2 Likes

I totally agree. I don’t want to spend 10 minutes on listening someone reading tables I can otherwise read in 1 min and interpret by myself (especially if they’are SUCH self-explanatory). Video should be used for telling stories or explaining things that are complex, for benchmarks plain text is unbeatable.

2 Likes